| It's a pleasant surprise that countertenor Daniel Taylor is approaching
something like superstardom, especially since most of his renown has come
through the exceedingly remote realm of baroque opera. Yes, early music
is in, and so are countertenors, but it's a stalwart audience
indeed that will sit through Handel's Rinaldo
or Theodora and come back for more.
Yet there are other things a countertenor can do. One is to team up with
a lutenist, preferably someone as good as Sylvain Bergeron, and record
a collection of 17th-century English Ballads and Folk Songs.
The present collection consists of 24 items, seven of them traditional
songs like Greensleeves and The Foggy Dew that everyone
knows, ten for lute alone and seven art songs by the likes of Dowland
and Campion.
Even those of us for whom the countertenor voice is not a favourite must
admit that Taylor sings beautifully. Taken individually, each song he
does is a gem. Fourteen songs with the same exotic timbre and roughly
similar tempos and melodic vocabularies become monotonous.
Bergeron must be one of the finest lutenists around. At least in this
repertoire his playing is a model of poise, taste and moderation.
Although I don't recommend this CD for repeated, attentive listening,
it would probably make excellent background music where a dreamy, archaic
ambience is what's called for.
|